The FEI has acknowledged the necessity to “discover a extra balanced and complete view of the game”, after proof was offered of “potential welfare points hiding in plain sight”.
H&H reported on photos despatched to the FEI, of “blue tongues” and open mouths in horses competing in World Cup dressage.
On 9 April, the group who submitted them, main veterinary researchers and a photographer, gave a presentation to the FEI and on the FEI’s invitation, made suggestions.
The presentation “contains high-definition visible proof documenting indicators of pressure-induced hurt in elite dressage horses – comparable to blue tongues, compressed oral and facial tissues, restricted airways and behavioural indicators of misery”, the group stated.
“We shared this materials with the FEI as a result of we consider the present physique of scientific data, spanning anatomy, physiology, physics, neuroscience, psychology and animal welfare science, is already adequate to behave. Additional invasive analysis would solely serve to copy what’s already evident.
“Our place is obvious: we don’t have to inflict extra ache on horses in experimental settings to show what we already know. What’s required now could be recognition and reform.”
Cristina Wilkins of the College of New England, who’s finding out for a PhD within the “one welfare” implications of horse-human interactions and has evented as much as four-star (now five-star) stage, defined that she has been reviewing welfare indicators. She stated high-definition fast-frame pictures captures extra info per second than video, and that photographer Crispin Parelius-Johannessen is a “essential member” of the group.
“We’ve been analyzing very carefully hundreds of pictures revealing facial particulars and figuring out potential welfare indicators that, with out this know-how, appear to be hiding in plain sight,” she stated.
“As we’ll present, having reviewed this proof, we’re involved that the pressures utilized exceed organic limits and that even in expert fingers, this stuff of kit pose a major welfare threat that have to be recognised for what it’s.”
She added: “We perceive that this isn’t intentional, that no one within the sport is deliberately harming horses or overlooking indicators of ache. However on condition that it’s going unnoticed, we felt a accountability to share our proof as quickly as we had reviewed it.
“We did this in alignment with the FEI’s acknowledged encouragement to talk up and report and to be horse guardians, and within the hope that our studies will probably be taken critically and acted upon promptly.”
The general image
One response to “blue tongue” pictures is commonly that they’re simply “a second in time”. However Mr Parelius-Johannessen, who can also be a rider, stated he took greater than 8,000 photos of every horse in its eight-minute take a look at. He demonstrated how every image adopted the following, with time stamps and that “these photographs present related welfare indicators consultant of your entire efficiency, not simply ‘moments in time’”.
Kati Tormola, a vet whose thesis was on bit-related accidents in competitors horses – and whose apply specialises in dentistry – identified “intense stares”, facial pressure and hyperflexion, suggesting ache, and unexplained “worrying” swellings.
David Mellor, an emeritus professor in animal welfare science and bioethics, and architect of the “5 domains” welfare mannequin, stated: “The proof is specific and unequivocal. The dressage horses in our information units are clearly in ache. Open mouth, quivering decrease lip, ache face. The seen compression and generally lesioning of the tongue, lips and gums and strain on the bars.”
Professor, vet and main researcher Paul McGreevy, from the College of Sydney, requested if “present judging standards have really grown to reward” indicators of ache or discomfort in horses, including that judges “should be capable of start to touch upon qualities comparable to concord. And that is solely potential when the horses are capable of specific themselves”.
Mrs Wilkins stated the group “believes there may be actual alternative for constructive change and potential to higher safeguard elite sport horse welfare”.
The group’s suggestions embrace revising judging standards to reward releases of contact or rein pressure and recognising that “pressure-induced tissue compromise, hyperflexion and indicators of worry and ache are proof of welfare compromise”. They’d additionally just like the FEI to undertake non-invasive instruments comparable to high-definition pictures to establish welfare points and combine these into judging and stewarding.
Welcoming the dialogue
An FEI spokesperson advised H&H the FEI “welcomes the dialogue” with the group and that its findings are being reviewed by the FEI veterinary committee.
“Most of the areas recognized are already being addressed by way of the FEI’s ongoing work, together with initiatives beneath the FEI dressage technique working group and the equine welfare technique motion plan,” she stated. “These efforts span a variety of subjects, from judging, scoring and tack/tools use to moral coaching and in-depth veterinary analysis, such because the oral cavity examine at the moment beneath approach.
“One key takeaway from [this presentation] was the necessity to discover a extra balanced and complete view of the game. The presentation opened the door to some considerate discussions across the broader context, and highlighted the worth of together with a wider vary of views to mirror the complexity and variety of equestrian sport.
“Whereas the controversy has largely centred on particular features like bit use, it’s essential to recognise the broader complexity of those points. We’re dedicated to a complete, evidence-based strategy that takes under consideration the total spectrum of things influencing horse welfare in sport.
“Constructive collaboration with the scientific neighborhood stays important to our progress, and we worth the chance to proceed participating with researchers and specialists to make sure that equestrian sport evolves with the welfare of the horse at all times as the highest precedence.”
The spokesperson added that there are those that break guidelines and that public notion has been affected by “severe however remoted circumstances of abuse and alleged cover-ups, which don’t precisely mirror the true dedication of the overwhelming majority of athletes, officers and members of the equestrian neighborhood to horse welfare and honest competitors”.
“Not all voices on this dialog share the identical imaginative and prescient for equestrian sport,” she stated. “Some teams basically oppose involvement of horses in competitors and should amplify issues in methods that don’t at all times mirror the total image. Whereas the FEI, after all, stays open to dialogue, our precedence have to be significant progress; directing our vitality in the direction of proactive options primarily based on scientific analysis, fairly than merely responding to criticism.”
You may additionally be curious about:
Credit score: Crispin Parelius Johannessen
Library picture.
Credit score: Mike Hewitt/Getty Photos
Credit score: Future
Keep in contact with all of the information within the run-up to and all through the most important exhibits and occasions throughout 2025 with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe right this moment for all you might want to know forward of those main occasions, plus on-line studies on the motion because it occurs from our skilled group of reporters and in-depth evaluation in our particular commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Arrange your limitless web site entry now
H&H information editor
Eleanor is an skilled journalist who spent over eight years working for native and nationwide newspapers earlier than becoming a member of H&H as information editor in March 2016. Enthusiastic about equine welfare and exposing the reality, Eleanor has reported on all features of the trade, from Brexit to anti-bullying campaigns, and from dressage guidelines to mules. Her sport of selection is showjumping, during which she competes her personal horses, and he or she additionally enjoys reporting at native leaping exhibits by way of to worldwide championships.
