Richard Sheane of prime Irish horse producers Cooley Farm explains why he feels vets analyzing X-rays with out having seen the horse within the flesh is influencing the gross sales of future equine stars
Right here at Cooley Farm, we’re having an ongoing downside, which is shared by many high-end horse gross sales yards. It’s widespread for a shopper to return in from overseas, purchase a horse topic to vetting and for the horse to be offered at their chosen Irish veterinary clinic for the pre-purchase examination.
The horse is clinically examined and X-rayed and when the whole lot is deemed regular, the X-rays and in some instances, scans, are despatched to the shopper’s residence vet. In lots of instances, they discover points which are irrelevant to the horse’s future efficiency. It could be one thing minor and inside regular limits, however their considerations imply the sale falls aside.
It appears like the house vet needs to indicate that they see greater than the vet who noticed the horse in particular person and that they’re defending their shoppers, however finally all they’re doing is stopping their shoppers from buying a prime horse.
The vet verify can actually solely assess the horse on the day – primarily by a scientific examination. Nobody has a crystal ball to foretell what the longer term holds and the horse might be injured in so some ways. If the vet is happy on the day, it’s ridiculous to base its future soundness on unfounded potential eventualities.
We estimate that 80% of the horses we’ve offered which have gone on to be positioned at four- and five-star have been judged unsuitable on this manner by a “third-party vet”.
Their careers reinforce a lesson we’ve discovered via a long time of expertise. Elite efficiency is constructed on capability, temperament, sturdiness and matching of horse to rider and the proper system – not on the misguided opinion of a vet who by no means considered the horse in particular person.
When assessed appropriately and in context, minor, non-prejudicial findings don’t impression soundness, efficiency, longevity or finally outcomes.
One Cooley graduate, who’s now succeeding at four-star and is likely one of the hottest up-and-coming horses within the sport, fell foul of at least seven totally different vets earlier than he discovered his residence – and he’s now beating a lot of the riders who turned him down.
Clients then generally complain that they didn’t purchase the horse “as a result of there was x, y, z improper with it” – however there wasn’t something improper with it, as its subsequent efficiency reveals.
“A deal with horses that can carry out”
We’re a top-end yard, not the equine dealing equal of a used automobile salesman, and that is affecting horses with a worth over £30,000.
We’re giving respectable cash for the horses initially and we now have them completely vetted. Now we have little interest in horses which have scientific or radiographic issues.
Our focus is on horses with distinctive temperament and talent – horses that can carry out on the highest degree.
Now we have a report for promoting horses which are nicely and sound – we’d don’t have any enterprise if we offered horses who weren’t as much as the job.
If somebody did ring up and had an issue with a horse, we’d take it again.
Vets maybe don’t realise how tough it’s to discover a horse with the potential for the highest degree after which to match the horse and the rider and system to create the proper formulation.
Assessing suitability for elite sport requires an understanding of temperament, capability, manufacturing methods and rider compatibility – areas that reach past the scope of a vet’s information.
When these broader elements should not absolutely thought of, pointless doubt could be launched by the vet into the decision-making course of, usually leading to riders and homeowners lacking horses that might have been a wonderful match for his or her system and objectives.
We do get our horses offered, in fact, however it’s such a rigmarole and it appears like we’re attending to the purpose the place vets have an excessive amount of management and they’re selecting horses, not riders.
In the end purchasers are shopping for horses that the vets like, not what’s finest for them and their future.
● Are you a vet with a unique view? Or a purchaser with an opinion? Write to us at hhletters@futurenet.com, together with your title, nearest city and county, for the prospect on your ideas to look in a forthcoming concern of the journal
You may also be concerned about:
Credit score: Peter Mooney
Library picture.
Credit score: Alamy Inventory Picture
Credit score: Lucy Merrell
Credit score: Elizabeth Barr
Credit score: Future
Keep in contact with all of the information within the run-up to and all through the main reveals and occasions throughout 2026 and past with a Horse & Hound subscription. Subscribe at present for all it’s essential know forward of those main occasions, plus on-line reviews on the motion because it occurs from our professional workforce of reporters and in-depth evaluation in our particular commemorative magazines. Have a subscription already? Arrange your limitless web site entry now
